Buzan writes, also in The Guardian: Slater's sensationalist book rehashes some of the old stuff, but offers some rumours that are entirely new to me.
For my first two years, she reports, my father kept me in a cramped square cage that was equipped with bells and food trays, and arranged for experiments that delivered rewards and punishments. And, contrary to hearsay, I didn't shoot myself in a bowling alley in Billings, Montana. Another criticism concerned Slater's description of her reaction to the David Rosenhan study.
In response to Corfield's criticism, Slater showed the New York Times an e-mail she received from Kagan, who was responding to a pre-publication fact-checking list she had sent him. that, in demonstrating to me that people do, indeed, have free will, you jumped under your desk ...," and Kagan responded: "I was trying to demonstrate that when humans have a choice of actions, they can select an act that has never been rewarded in the past ..." Deborah Skinner Buzan, younger daughter of psychologist B. Skinner, has questioned the thoroughness of Slater's research.
She has criticized Slater for repeating rumors that Buzan was abused by her father and became mentally ill as a result, and alleges that Slater failed to approach her for comment before publication.
I don’t think I was born into it, although it’s possible that I was.
In Kindergarten, when we were learning to read, our teacher wrote C-A-T on the board. In fact, the books in my study are largely the books that I learned on. In my twenties, I would read Faulkner, for instance, and halfway through a story, I would stop reading.
Her 2004 Opening Skinner's Box: Great Psychological Experiments of the Twentieth Century, a description of psychology experiments "narrated as stories," Criticism has focused on Slater's research methods and on the extent to which some of the experiences she describes may have been fictionalized.
Other awards Slater has won include the 1993 New Letters Literary Award in creative non-fiction, and the 1994 Missouri Review Award, and her work was included in The Best American Essays of 19.
Slater's attorney has responded to the criticism by accusing some psychiatrists and psychologists of having mounted a "vindictive effort" and "vendetta" against her, and of "sniping" at her on
David Corfield, a philosopher of mathematics writing in The Guardian, questions the veracity of the book's reported speech.