Quine Ontological Relativity And Other Essays

Quine Ontological Relativity And Other Essays-34
The basic conception of philosophy and philosophical practice that informs his discussion of science is commonly know as naturalism, a view that recommends the “abandonment of the goal of a first philosophy prior to natural science” (1981, 67), which further involves a “readiness to see philosophy as natural science trained upon itself and permitted free use of scientific findings” (1981, 85) and lastly, recognizes that “…it is within science itself, and not in some prior philosophy, that reality is to be identified and described” (1981, 21).

Quine’s philosophy should then be seen as a systematic attempt to understand science from within the resources of science itself.

This project investigates both the epistemological and ontological dimensions of scientific theorizing.

Analytic statements do not then make any claims about the world, but are the product of the specific way we construct a language.

With the a priori (now thought of as analytic) character of logic and mathematics depicted in such terms, it does not constitute a separate type of knowledge, and does then conflict with the empiricist commitment that all knowledge has its source in experience.

This is because, in part, his use of the term "science" applies quite broadly referring not simply to the ‘hard’ or natural sciences, but also including psychology, economics, sociology, and even history (Quine 1995, 19; also see Quine 1997).

But a more substantive reason centers on his view that all knowledge strives to provide a true understanding of the world and is then responsive to observation as the ultimate test of its claims.Quine’s view of philosophical inquiry breaks decisively with the conception of philosophy’s relation to science as seen in Plato, Descartes and Kant.Although he finds himself more in sympathy with the empiricist tradition (this is especially true with regard to both Russell’s and Carnap’s distinctive attempts to make philosophy more scientific), he also rejects what he sees as its attempt to preserve the a priori status of logic and mathematics through the distinction between analytic and synthetic statements (1981, 67-72).Quine’s epistemological concern is to examine our successful acquisition of scientific theories, while his ontological interests focus on the further logical regimentation of that theory.He thus advocates what is more famously known as ‘naturalized epistemology’, which consists of his attempt to provide an improved scientific explanation of how we have developed elaborate scientific theories on the basis of meager sensory input.On this general picture, philosophy is not conceived as a science, but as distinct from experience and experiment and further providing resources that constitute a secure foundation for scientific claims.The empiricist tradition in philosophy, stretching from Locke to Russell, with its view that all substantial knowledge finds its source in experience, provides a useful contrast to this conception of philosophy.Quine further argues that the most general features of reality can be examined through the use of formal logic by clarifying what objects we must acknowledge as real given our acceptance of an overarching systematic view of the world.In pursuing these issues, Quine reformulates and thus transforms these philosophical concerns according to those standards of clarity, empirical adequacy, and utility that he takes as central to the explanatory power of empirical science.Empiricists have been more sympathetic with the idea of aligning philosophy more closely to science, but there remained a problem concerning the nature of logical and mathematical knowledge, which did not appear to depend on experience.Rudolf Carnap’s logical empiricism with its use of the analytic-synthetic distinction is often presented as responding to this specific epistemological challenge (see Quine 1995a; for dissenting views see Richardson 1998, Friedman 2006).

SHOW COMMENTS

Comments Quine Ontological Relativity And Other Essays

  • The Future of Ontology After Ontological Relativity
    Reply

    Ontological commitments are very important. Ontological commitment influences one’s entire philosophy. Ontological commitment influences one's entire philosophy. This paper will examine the ontological commitment of W. V. Quine. He is the most influential analytical philosopher of the twentieth century.…

  • Ontological Relativity and Other Essays - W V Quine - Häftad.
    Reply

    Pris 529 kr. Häftad, 1969. Skickas inom 3-6 vardagar. Köp Ontological Relativity and Other Essays av W V Quine på…

  • Ontological Relativity and Other Essays Quine, W. V. - b.
    Reply

    Main Ontological Relativity and Other Essays. Ontological Relativity and Other Essays Quine, W. V. Year 1969…

  • Ontological Relativity and Other Essays - Google Books
    Reply

    Intended to clarify the meaning of the philosophical doctrines propounded by W. V. Quine in Word and Objects, the essays included herein are intimately related and concern themselves with three philosophical preoccupations the nature of meaning, the meaning of existence and the nature of natural knowledge.…

  • W. V. Quine. Ontological relativity and other essays.
    Reply

    Ontological relativity and other essays MANLEY THOMPSON. UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO. Search for more papers by this author. MANLEY THOMPSON. UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO.…

  • W. V. Quine's Professional Published and Unpublished Essays.
    Reply

    Books and Essays on W. V. Quine, mathematician and philosopher including list of books, articles, essays, published and unpublished items are included. Includes links to other Willard Van Orman Quine Internet resources as well as to other Family Web Sites by Douglas Boynton Quine.…

  • Epistemology Naturalized - Langara iWeb
    Reply

    Epistemology Naturalized W. V. QUINE A selection from “Epistemology Naturalized”, with summaries of omitted sections written by me. Originally published in Ontological Relativity and Other Essays, by W. V. Quine New York Columbia University Press. identified bodies outright with the sense impressions. If…

  • Essay essay in j dewey ontological other philosophy relativity
    Reply

    Essay essay in j dewey ontological other philosophy relativity Ontological Relativity & Other Essays increasingly assigned philosophy a less dramatic role by taking on. daniel dennett, a student of quine's, falls into this category, as does stephen toulmin, who arrived at his philosophical position via wittgenstein, whom he calls "a pragmatist of a sophisticated kind" foreword for dewey 1929.…

The Latest from hot-com.ru ©